No One Should Take the Catholic Church Seriously
Because they’re not a serious organization:
In France, the shrine at Lourdes is surrounded by hundreds of hotels and has received as many as 45,000 pilgrims in a single day. Our Lady of Guadalupe, in Mexico, draws millions of fervent worshipers a year.
Now, a little chapel among the dairy farms here, called Our Lady of Good Help, has joined that august company in terms of religious status, if not global fame. This month, it became one of only about a dozen sites worldwide, and the first in the United States, where apparitions of the Virgin Mary have been officially validated by the Roman Catholic Church. (emphasis mine)
Oh wow! If the Catholic Church says it’s real, it must be legitimate, right? Let’s examine their meticulous reasoning process.
- In 1859, a woman claimed she saw the virgin Mary appear three times.
- Serious theologians spend two years “investigating,” to determine there was no fraud or heresy.
- The church declares with “moral certainty” that this is the real deal!
Uh huh… I see. What would science have to say about this?
- Anecdotal evidence is no kind of evidence at all, especially when it’s over 150 years old and not even first-hand. Not to mention the witness describes Mary’s “flowing blond locks,” which seems pretty unlikely. Sounds like a clear-cut case of religious delusion.
- Let’s have a snack!


































